W-2 Thinking Will Break Your Business (Here’s How to Shift It)

The Gig
Written By Claire King

by Natalie Hoop

You started your business to be free.
But if it still feels hard, heavy, or chaotic — you might’ve brought something with you.
Your W-2 mindset.

W-2 thinking will break your business.
And most people don’t even realize they’re doing it.

The Wake-Up Moment

I learned this the hard way.

One of my very first fractional clients should’ve been a dream: flexible hours, good pay, interesting work. But after a few months, I was completely burned out and I couldn’t figure out why.

I was jumping through hoops to make the client happy. Giving up my nights, my boundaries, and my focus time. He questioned if I wasn’t online. The scope changed daily. And worst of all, I let it.

At one point I thought: At least in a W-2 role I had benefits and PTO to deal with this kind of stress.

That’s when it hit me.
The issue wasn’t him. It was me.
I was still operating like an employee — not a business owner.

5 Signs You’re Still Thinking Like an Employee

If you're feeling overwhelmed, underpaid, or stuck in your business, you might not need a new strategy. You might need a new mindset.

Here’s how to tell if your old W-2 habits are holding you back:

1. You say yes to work you don’t want

You feel bad turning down projects, even if they drain you. You justify it by saying, “I need the money”, but deep down, you know the work is wrong for you.

2. You underprice yourself

You’re afraid higher rates will scare people off. So you discount. You throw in extras. You overdeliver. And you quietly resent it all.

3. You blur every boundary

You respond to emails at 10pm. You’re “always on.” You let clients rescope mid-project and tell yourself it's just part of being flexible.

4. You fear losing clients more than protecting your business

You think: If I say no, I’ll lose them. If I push back, they’ll leave. You prioritize keeping clients happy, even when it’s costing you clarity, time, and sanity.

5. You feel guilty resting

You take breaks with a side of shame. You keep receipts of your busyness in case anyone questions your value. You still think productivity = worth.

Here’s the Real Cost

When you bring an employee mindset into your business, you don’t just stall your growth.

You invite burnout.
You build resentment.
You create chaos.
And eventually — you consider giving up.

Not because you're lazy. Not because you're unskilled.
But because you’re still making decisions like someone who works for a company instead of someone building one.

W-2 thinking doesn’t just slow you down — it builds a business that drains you.
And if you don’t shift out of it, it will eventually break what you’re trying to build.

Time to Make the Shift

This shift isn’t easy. But it is essential.

You have to unlearn the habits that made you a great employee — and replace them with the ones that make you a sustainable business owner.

You didn’t quit your job to recreate it.
Build the business you actually want to work in.

One Last Thing

If this feels familiar — you’re not broken.
You’re just still thinking like an employee.
And that’s something you can shift.

Want more insights like this?

I help fractional leaders make this transition every day. If you want support as you do the same:

Contributor Bio
Natalie Hoop is a Fractional Strategic Ops Partner and founder of The Fractional Launch Lab. She helps founders scale without stalling or burning out their teams by fixing the operational systems behind growth and she coaches experienced leaders to build sustainable businesses of their own.

About Onward
Onward is a membership for healthcare, perks, and career support to help you thrive, no matter how your work is classified. Whether you’re self-employed, between gigs, or exploring alternatives, Onward gives you access to benefits that fit your life on your terms.

Learn more at onwardbenefits.com.

Claire King
Next

The Future of Benefits Starts With You